Blog

A Penalty Provision in the Marital Settlement Agreement

 

In New Jersey divorces, marital settlement agreements include language that addresses the ramifications if either person breaches any provision of the agreement.  Often, the agreement includes a penalty provision that requires breaching party to pay the other’s counsel fees if the matter requires court intervention.  More often than not, courts have largely ignored such penalty provisions.  By not enforcing this provision, it lost its power and deterrence of breaches. 

However, a recent New Jersey appellate division case, Holtham, Jr. v. Lucas, was upheld and the penalty provision was enforced.  Previously, the trial court assessed an $18,450 sanction against the husband.  This figure represented $150 per day for each and every day he remained in violation of the agreement. 

The court placed a significant amount of weight on the public policy of enforcing agreements.  As such, it considered this bargained for penalty provision necessary ensure peace for both parties post-divorce.  Because it was a vital piece of the agreement, it warranted its enforcement. 

The court held that the parties entered into the agreement with relative bargaining power.  Similarly, the parties also had sufficient sophistication and understanding of the provision.  And, both had the benefit of counsel. 

In conclusion, this is an important case.  It empowers courts to properly sanction those who willfully and wrongfully violate bargained for terms of an agreement. 

Please contact me with questions about marital settlement agreements, or other family law matters.

Subscribe to Our Blog

SHARE THIS POST:

Related Posts

Blog
Is January Really “Divorce Month?”

“Divorce Month” Fact or Fiction: Do More Couples Split in January? was a recent article that I came across in the New York Times. The article discusses the belief that January is the busiest month of the year for divorce filings. The article’s information is consistent with my experiences after practicing family law for many…

Read More
Blog
One Year!

One year into owning and running my own firm has been exhilarating, amazing, exhausting with a million other emotions in between. When the news was first announced, many of my friends, who are also solo and small firm owners, reached out to me to try and prepare me for the wild ride I was about…

Read More
Blog
Divorce Consultations – Are You Prepared?

I spend a significant of my day providing initial divorce consultations. This is the most important time I will spend with a potential client. In these consultations, many of the people that come see me are understandably emotional and focused on the part of the relationship that led them to my office. More often than…

Read More
Blog
Divorce Issues for New Jersey and Federal Government Officials

For many of us, the first time that we heard of family issues affecting government officials started with the philandering of President Clinton. These days, the media feeds us the personal and private affairs of former Congresswoman Katie Hill and former FBI lawyer, Lisa Page, among others. Going through a divorce is a stressful time…

Read More
Blog
Divorcing Police Officers Face Unique Parenting Time Issues

Divorcing police officers and firefighters, like other clients, face a multitude of issues.  For most parties, the paramount concern is custody and parenting time when there are children born of the marriage. For most parents who work “9 to 5” jobs, there will be a traditional custody and parenting time arrangement.  This agreement is either…

Read More
Blog
Private School Costs in New Jersey Divorces

In a New Jersey case where the parties’ agreement calls for them to “equally divide…school costs,” and one party does not contribute to the costs for years, even though not explicitly asked to do so, a court can enforce the agreement and compel contribution. In the unpublished Appellate Division case of Fanelli v. Hnatowski, the…

Read More
Call Now ButtonCall Us